Nina Noir, Fictional Editor and Case of the Strange Thing that Actually Works for Aspiring Authors

I'm Nina Noir, Fictional Editor. 

Last week I introduced you to aspiring paranormal romance novelist Buffy Armstrong, whose novella The Dark King's Lover finalled in the 2nd Annual Novellas Need Love, Too contest sponsored by the Celtic Hearts Chapter of the Romance Writers of America in the Paranormal category.

That led up to what I called the "strange thing" I see working for aspiring novelists that has nothing to do with virtuosity, decades of craft development, or industry connections. Believe me, I have an array of clients who run the gamut, but over the years I've started to pick up on a pattern of publishing success that may be truly surprising to you.

So, what is it?

First, let's take a look.

I have some clients who will spend a half-year doing targeting submissions and then give up when their twelve or fifteen queries catch no fish. Other clients who will spend years perfecting a manuscript then submit to a handful of their favorite agents, get no responses then put the manuscript away.

But then there are Buffy ad Lori, one who just finalled in a novella contest, and the other who just landed her first publisher. Of all my clients, these two have seen the greatest Return on Investment for their writing over the past year. 

So, how did they do it?

First, let's look at what they have in common:

• They both happen to be woman doing well in the business world 
• Both spend their days working with deadline-driven project goals 
• Both love to spend their evenings and weekends writing
• Both finish a project and immediately think "Where is this going to go?"
• Both are smart about submitting to publishers in their niche
• Both are willing to invest money in editors, auctions, and contests
• Both women have been submitting their manuscripts, and reworking them based on the feedback they receive, for over a year

Here is what they do differently from each other:

Buffy writes paranormal romance, has an online author platform, and focuses on specific goals: a contest, a pitch session, a submission deadline. And she works on her novels, but she also knows when to kick them out of the door. 

Lori writes romance-suspense, has no author platform, and sends her work out to multiple freelance editors to get a wide array of editing and publishing advice. Then she bids on agent/editor auctions to get her manuscript IN FRONT OF agents and editors who can actually make things happen.

Here is what they do differently from my other clients (and me)

Both Buffy and Lori are competitive, like many of my other clients, but have a more methodical, prolific, and proactive approach to submission. They focus on specific goals and keep on chugging forward. They don't get too bogged down in self-doubt over rejections, or put manuscript away to sulk for years. Maybe it's because their first identities aren't as writers, so they have less ego to wound. 

Either way, what does it all add up to?

Endurance. That's it.

They both set specific publishing goals and don't give up until they meet them.

It goes like this:

You work toward a contest or submission deadline then, when a rejection comes, immediately move on to the next goal. Don't stop after a year of rejections. Keep perfecting the manuscript, but also keep submitting.

So, what can you do?

Find a contest (specific to your genre and subject matter is best) where you can submit your next poem, short story, or novella. There are literally dozens taking place at any given time and can be easily located online with a quick search. Give up the $10 or $25 it will take to enter. The fire that an objective deadline will light in your belly is well worth the cost.

If you have hundreds or thousands of dollars laying around, bid on an editor/agent auction. If you win, they HAVE to look at your manuscript. They might still say no, but you'll be that much closer to getting industry feedback and then you can just try it again. Just as "writing is rewriting," "submitting is resubmitting."

You don't have to spend lots of money, but you do have to keep your eyes on the prize. That is what I see working for my clients anyway. Determination and endurance. It will outstrip everything else. 

And join me in the future for new installments of Nina Noir, Fictional Editor.

Now get outta my office. This dry, dirty vodka martini isn't gonna drink itself.